Collaborative Divorce vs. Contested Divorce: Which Is Right for You?

No one walks into a marriage expecting it to end. But when it becomes clear that separation is the next chapter, the decisions you make now—how you divorce—can shape the well-being of your children, your finances, and your emotional peace for years to come.

At The Goodman Law Firm, we believe that not all divorces have to be battles. Sometimes, the healthiest path forward is one where both parties commit to resolution instead of war. But in other cases, standing your ground in court may be the only way to protect what matters most.

So, how do you know what’s right for your family?

What Is a Collaborative Divorce?

A Team-Based, Non-Adversarial Process

Collaborative divorce is a structured legal process where both spouses commit to resolving their divorce outside of court. Unlike litigation, which positions spouses as opponents, collaborative divorce is rooted in problem-solving, open communication, and cooperation.

The goal isn’t to “win”—it’s to work through tough issues together and arrive at a mutually agreeable settlement that protects everyone involved, especially the children.

Who’s Involved?

While each spouse retains their own collaboratively trained attorney, the process often brings in a supportive team of professionals, depending on your family’s needs:

• Child specialists to help protect children’s emotional well-being
• Financial neutrals to guide fair asset division and support planning
• Therapists or divorce coaches to improve communication and reduce conflict
• Mediators to keep discussions on track and productive

This team approach ensures that each part of your divorce—legal, emotional, and financial—is handled with care and expertise.

The Legal Framework in North Carolina

Collaborative divorce is formally recognized and governed under North Carolina’s Collaborative Law statutes, which require parties and their attorneys to sign a Participation Agreement. This contract confirms their commitment to transparency and a court-free process.

Here’s the catch: if the collaborative process fails, both attorneys must withdraw, and the spouses must hire new lawyers to proceed with litigation. This encourages all parties to give the process their full effort.

The Core Principles

At its heart, collaborative divorce is built on three guiding values:

• Open communication – No secrets, no games. Just honest, respectful dialogue.
• Voluntary disclosure – Both sides share all relevant information without being forced by subpoenas or court orders.
• A commitment not to litigate – Everyone agrees: if we can’t solve it together, we walk away and start over in court with different attorneys.

For many families, especially those who share children, collaborative divorce offers a more peaceful path forward—one that prioritizes healing over hostility.

Pros and Cons: Collaborative Divorce

Pros of Collaborative Divorce

Protects Children from Courtroom Trauma

Divorce is hard enough on children. Collaborative divorce keeps families out of the courtroom, reducing stress and shielding kids from the emotional fallout of a public legal battle. When parents can resolve conflict respectfully, children benefit immensely.

Often Faster and More Cost-Effective

Litigation can drag on for months—or even years. In contrast, collaborative divorce often moves more efficiently, saving you time, money, and emotional wear and tear. When both parties are committed to resolution, progress happens faster.

Encourages Problem-Solving and Cooperation

Because the process is centered on mutual agreement, collaborative divorce fosters a spirit of compromise. With the help of a professional team, couples learn how to work through conflict constructively—skills that are especially important for co-parenting after divorce.

Confidential and Private

Unlike court proceedings, which are public record, collaborative divorce happens behind closed doors. Your family’s private matters stay just that—private.

Cons of Collaborative Divorce

Requires Mutual Trust and Cooperation

For the process to succeed, both parties must be willing to communicate openly, disclose all relevant information, and act in good faith. If one person isn’t fully on board, collaboration can stall quickly.

No Backup Plan if It Fails

One of the most important things to understand about collaborative divorce in North Carolina: if the process breaks down, both attorneys must withdraw. You’ll need to start over with new legal counsel—often costing you more time, money, and stress.

What Is a Contested Divorce?

A Court-Driven Process When Agreements Break Down

A contested divorce is a traditional, litigated divorce where spouses cannot agree on one or more key issues—often related to children, finances, or property. In these cases, the court steps in to make decisions for the couple, based on the evidence presented and what the judge determines is fair and lawful.

It’s a formal process. It’s often lengthy. And it can be emotionally and financially taxing. But for many families, especially in high-conflict or unsafe situations, it is absolutely necessary.

Common Disputes That Lead to Contested Divorce

Some of the most frequent points of contention include:

• Child custody and visitation – When parents disagree on where the child should live or how parenting time should be shared.
• Equitable distribution of property – Dividing assets and debts fairly under North Carolina’s equitable distribution laws.
• Alimony or spousal support – When there’s a dispute over whether one spouse should financially support the other, and how much.

These aren’t easy conversations. And when cooperation breaks down, the court becomes the final decision-maker.

What the Process Looks Like

Here’s what to expect in a contested divorce in North Carolina:

1. Filing a Complaint – One spouse (the plaintiff) formally initiates the divorce by filing legal documents with the court.
2. Serving the Other Party – The other spouse (the defendant) must be legally notified.
3. Discovery – Both sides exchange financial records, witness statements, and other relevant information.
4. Court Hearings – Attorneys present evidence and arguments to the judge, often over several appearances.
5. Judge’s Decision – The court issues final orders that both parties must follow.

This process can take several months—or longer—and is often emotionally draining. But in many cases, it’s the only path to protecting your legal rights and your family’s safety.

When Contested Divorce Is the Right Option

At The Goodman Law Firm, we know that sometimes, collaboration just isn’t possible.

A contested divorce may be necessary when:

• There is domestic violence or abuse
• One party refuses to negotiate in good faith
• There are serious disagreements over parenting, finances, or fairness
• Protecting children from a harmful environment is the priority

When your future and your children’s well-being are at stake, you need a family law advocate who knows how to fight—and when to do so with purpose.

Pros and Cons: Contested Divorce

Pros of Contested Divorce

Judicial Decisions in High-Conflict or Unsafe Situations

When communication breaks down, or when there’s a power imbalance, mental health concern, or abuse, contested divorce puts important decisions in the hands of a judge—not the other party. This can level the playing field when cooperation is no longer an option.

Court-Enforced Outcomes

Court orders carry legal weight. If your spouse refuses to comply with a custody agreement, child support order, or property division ruling, the court has tools to enforce compliance. That legal backing matters—especially when one party is uncooperative.

Protective Measures When Necessary

In cases involving domestic violence or harassment, contested divorce allows for protective orders (like restraining orders) and emergency custody hearings to ensure your immediate safety and the protection of your children.

Cons of Contested Divorce

Expensive and Time-Consuming

Litigation is rarely quick or affordable. Between attorney fees, court filings, expert witnesses, and extended timelines, a contested divorce can become a significant financial burden.

Emotionally Draining—Especially for Children

When parents are adversaries in court, children often feel caught in the middle. The courtroom environment can increase tension and emotional fallout, particularly in custody battles.

Public Record

Unlike collaborative divorce, contested divorce is public. That means details about your finances, custody disputes, and personal matters may be accessible in court records—something many families would prefer to avoid.

Less Control Over the Outcome

Perhaps most importantly, once your case is in front of a judge, you’re no longer in control. The final decision rests in the court’s hands, not yours—and that outcome may not reflect your values or priorities.

Choosing the Divorce Path That’s Right for You

Divorce isn’t easy—but the way you approach it can make a life-changing difference.

If you and your spouse are willing to collaborate, communicate, and prioritize peaceful resolution, collaborative divorce offers a respectful, private, and often more affordable path forward. It’s ideal for couples who are solution-focused and want to preserve a working relationship—especially for the sake of their children.

But if cooperation is no longer on the table—or if safety, fairness, or protection is at stake—contested divorce may be the necessary route. In these situations, court intervention can offer structure, legal authority, and protection for what matters most.

With the right legal partner by your side, you can move forward with confidence, clarity, and care.

Take the Next Step with The Goodman Law Firm, PLLC

📞 Call us today at (704) 502-6773

📍 10020 Monroe Road, Suite 170-288, Matthews, NC 28105
📩 kg@goodmanlawnc.com

🌐 www.goodmanlawnc.com

‍